Sidney Crosby has recently arose in conversations as a top 5 player all time, and it’s about time. Crosby has easily reined the NHL as the best player in the league over the past ten years. So if anything he is overdue for being considered by many as a top 5 player all time. Crosby has many reasons to be considered, and I will try to touch on those.
To begin, the easiest argument would be his insane stats. Right now he sits at sixth all-time on the points per game stat, which in my opinion, is a great stat to show how offensively talented a player is. The reason being, that a player could play 1000 games and have 700 points, while a player that only played 600 games could have 600 points. The points per game stat obviously shows that the second player had a better offensive impact as he averaged one point per game and player one only averaged .7 points per game. Also, the fact that Crosby is sixth all time, and playing in the hardest era yet to score in is also a testimony to how great of a player he is. The next closest player from this era on that list…is none other than Evgeni Malkin. Crosby has also scored 100 plus points in 5 out of 8 seasons where he played more than 70 games. If it wasn’t for all his injuries, we can only wonder how much his stat line would be improved. And lastly he has been a 1+ point per game player every season of his career.
The second thing that attributes to his ever-growing legacy is his extensive trophy case. Crosby has already captained the Penguins to two Stanley cups and has a chance to captain them to their third if they can win two of the next five games. Crosby also has two Olympic gold medals, one World Junior Championship gold, and a World Cup gold. He also has a plethora of individual awards to tack onto that. He has two Art Ross trophies, two Maurice Rocket Richard trophies, three Ted Lindsay awards, two Hart trophies, two Messier awards, one World Cup MVP, and one Conn Smythe trophy. Those are his best trophies or awards, there are much more but listing them all would make the article an extra page long.
Lastly, Crosby’s play style can be argued as an equal if not better argument for him being a top 5 player all time. Crosby was mainly offensive in his game up until roughly 2015. Ever since 2015, Crosby’s ability to play both sides of the puck has really taken a fore front. He is now more physical than ever on both sides of the puck, and has shown that he can shut his opponents down in key moments of the game. Most analysts are using his two-way play to justify him being a top 5 player of all-time. The same argument was used to show why Crosby was the best player in the NHL this year despite being slightly outscored by Connor McDavid. McDavid is yet to show he can play adequate defense and it mainly offensive oriented. Stats don’t show the whole story in sports, and Crosby’s play is what truly sets him apart from the rest.
Overall, it should be a no brainer that Crosby is a top 5 player all-time, however there are still critics out there. The good news is that his legacy can only go on from here on out, and he still has many years left to leave his mark.